By default, email is not encrypted: messages travel in plain text along mail servers, which means the content could theoretically be intercepted and read. With S/MIME or PGP you encrypt the content of your email so that only the recipient with the right key can read the message. This article explains the difference and shows how to set it up in commonly used mail programs.
Why encrypt email?
Regular email is often secured in transit via TLS between servers, but that only protects the transport. Once the message is on a server, the content can in principle be viewed. Encrypting the content itself (end-to-end) ensures that even the mail server cannot read the message. This is especially relevant for sensitive information such as contracts, medical data, financial figures, or personal data.
In addition, digital signing (which is often used together with encryption) provides assurance that a message really comes from the sender and has not been altered in transit.
S/MIME vs PGP: the difference
S/MIME works with certificates issued by a certificate authority, similar to SSL certificates for websites. This makes it suitable for organizations: it’s built into Outlook, Apple Mail, and most business mail clients, and often works without the recipient needing to install anything.
PGP (Pretty Good Privacy, nowadays often OpenPGP) works with a key pair you generate yourself: a public key that you share and a private key that you keep secret. There’s no central issuer needed, but you do need to exchange public keys with each other and often install a plugin.
Setting up S/MIME step by step
Request an S/MIME certificate
Request an email certificate from a certificate authority that offers S/MIME. You usually need a verified email address for this.
Install the certificate
Import the certificate (usually a .p12 file) into your operating system or directly into your mail program, for example via the settings of Outlook or Apple Mail.
Link the certificate to your account
Go to the account settings in your mail program and select the certificate for signing and/or encrypting outgoing email.
Exchange public keys
To be able to send encrypted mail, you also need the recipient’s public key. Request a signed message, then it will be sent along automatically.
Test an encrypted message
Send a test message and check whether the lock or certificate icon is visible in the recipient’s mail client.
Setting up PGP step by step
Install a PGP tool
Use an OpenPGP application or plugin that fits your mail program, for example an add-on for Thunderbird or a separate program for key management.
Generate your key pair
Create a public and private key. Store the private key safely and set a strong password; without this key, you can no longer decrypt encrypted messages.
Share your public key
Send your public key to contacts or place it on a keyserver so that others can send you encrypted messages.
Import contacts’ keys
Add each recipient’s public key to your key management before sending an encrypted message to that person.
Send and verify
Set your mail program to sign and/or encrypt messages by default, and check upon receipt whether the signature is valid.
If you use a business email address via business email hosting, you can usually just add S/MIME or PGP to your existing mail program without having to change anything on your mail server. Questions about your mail settings can always be found in the knowledge base.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use S/MIME and PGP at the same time?
Yes, but not for the same message. You choose per recipient or situation which method to use, depending on what they support.
What happens if I lose my private key?
Without your private key, you can no longer read old encrypted messages. Always keep a secure backup of your key in a separate location.
Does encrypted email also work on mobile?
That depends on the app. Apple Mail supports S/MIME natively; for PGP on mobile you often need a separate app or plugin.
Does this also protect against spam and phishing?
No, encryption protects the content from being read, but it’s not a replacement for spam filtering or measures such as SPF, DKIM, and DMARC.
Conclusion
S/MIME and PGP encrypt the content of your email so that only the intended recipient can read it. S/MIME works with certificates and is simpler to use within organizations, while PGP offers more flexibility but also requires more technical knowledge. Choose the method that fits your contacts and workflow.